Winchester Spent $37K Fighting Gun Ban, Then Quietly Dropped It
Winchester, Virginia, spent more than two years and over $37,000 defending a ban on firearms in its public parking garages, then rewrote the law before a judge could rule on it, FOIA records obtained by AmmoLand News show.
Snapshot
The city paid $35,862.78 to defense firm McGavin, Boyce, Bardot, Thorsen & Katz between January 2024 and June 2026, plus $1,310 billed by City Attorney Melisa Michelsen's own firm, Litten & Sipe. Before a court decided whether the garage ban was constitutional, Winchester amended its ordinance in May 2026 to exempt public parking structures, and the lawsuit, Hyland v. The City of Winchester, was dismissed as moot.
Key points
- Seven payments: The defense firm's checks ranged from $1,281.50 to $10,630.32, covering work from January 2024 through June 2026.
- No hourly records released: The city told requesters it had "no additional responsive documents" showing the defense firm's billing rate or detailed invoices, unlike the itemized bills from its own city attorney's firm.
- Agreed order first, repeal later: A June 2024 agreed order blocked enforcement in the named garages; the city didn't formally amend the ordinance until May 2026, after discovery and a summary judgment motion.
- Groups behind the suit: The Gun Owners Foundation and the Virginia Citizens Defense League backed the challenge; Gun Owners of America's Erich Pratt told the Daily Caller News Foundation the case was nearing deposition of Winchester's police chief when the city acted.
Quick take
The city never explained its reversal, and AmmoLand's John Crump writes that his own read is that Winchester saw a loss coming and chose to fold rather than let a court rule against it. Whether that's right or not, the pattern matters: a city spent over two years and tens of thousands of dollars defending a gun-free zone that it ultimately gave up without a ruling, and residents still can't see what the defense lawyers charged per hour.
Read the full story: ammoland.com