SAF Presses ATF for Proof After Pardoned Pastor's Guns Destroyed Before Clemency
President Trump pardoned Oklahoma pastor Russell Fincher in September 2026, but the Second Amendment Foundation says ATF destroyed 39 of his forfeited firearms months earlier, and the agency cannot produce video proof of what happened to them.
Snapshot
According to the Second Amendment Foundation's Investigative Journalism Project, ATF Director Robert Cekada told Fincher his 39 forfeited firearms were destroyed, with documentation citing a June 12, 2026 destruction date that conflicts with what Fincher says he was originally told. SAF has filed a FOIA request for video evidence, and Cekada reportedly confirmed no footage of the actual destruction exists.
Key points
- Timeline conflict: SAF reports Fincher was initially told the destruction occurred in August, but ATF documents reportedly list June 12, 2026, nearly three months before the pardon.
- No video exists: Cekada reportedly clarified that cameras at the West Virginia facility were for security, not for recording destruction, and confirmed no footage of the firearms being destroyed was made.
- Plea history matters: Fincher agreed not to contest forfeiture of the 39 guns as part of a 2024 plea deal, a distinction the article notes limits what a pardon can legally undo.
- Pattern of friction: SAF also reported that Fincher and pardoned veteran Patrick "Tate" Adamiak were both denied firearm purchases after receiving clemency, denials Cekada attributed to the FBI rather than ATF.
- Open records fight: SAF's November 17 FOIA request seeks the underlying destruction and inventory records as independent confirmation of ATF's account.
Quick take
A pardon clears a conviction, not necessarily a property dispute, and AmmoLand's Duncan Johnson argues that distinction doesn't excuse an agency from documenting what it did with someone's seized collection. The paper trail ATF describes may satisfy internal procedure, but it isn't the independent proof Fincher is asking for. Watch how SAF's FOIA request plays out.
Read the full story: ammoland.com