Maryland's Carry Rule Punishes Orthodox Jews for Not Driving on Shabbat
A Montgomery County, Maryland gun rule meant to govern carry near houses of worship has created a situation where an armed congregant can legally drive to synagogue but can't walk there, even though Orthodox Jewish religious practice forbids driving on Shabbat.
Snapshot
Rabbi Menashe Shapiro, a volunteer armed security member at the Silver Spring Jewish Center, can carry his firearm inside the synagogue under a September court ruling, but faces a civil fine for carrying it on his walk there, since the law only exempts guns carried within 100 yards while driving. Becket, the religious liberty group representing the synagogue, argues the rule guts the very right it claims to protect.
Key points
- The rule itself: Montgomery County's firearm law bars carrying within 100 yards of a house of worship except for those driving through the zone.
- The real-world effect: Shapiro and other Orthodox congregants don't drive on Shabbat, so the "driving" exemption is useless to the very people who rely on armed volunteer security for services.
- Becket's argument: Senior counsel Eric Baxter told the Forward it makes no sense to protect carry inside the building "if you can't get to the synagogue," and says the law effectively singles out observant Jews.
- The legal backdrop: A September court ruling created the current carry allowance inside the synagogue, but left the walking restriction intact, producing what Bearing Arms calls an irrational two-tier outcome.
Quick take
Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton argues this isn't a typical Second Amendment gripe but a law that manages to trip over the First Amendment too, since it penalizes people for following their faith's rules on travel. He notes even non-Jewish visitors could legally carry up to the building in ways Shapiro cannot. Whether a legislative fix or further litigation follows is unclear, but the setup as it stands looks hard to defend on safety grounds alone.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com