First Circuit Reopens Gun Rights Case Over Old DUI Convictions
The First Circuit has revived a New Hampshire man's Second Amendment challenge to a federal gun ban tied to two decades-old DUI convictions, ruling that an older circuit precedent no longer controls the analysis under Bruen.
Snapshot
On November 13, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit vacated the dismissal of Thomas Marshall's lawsuit over his 1997 and 2005 Massachusetts DUI convictions, which blocked him from buying a firearm under 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1). The court held that its 2011 ruling in United States v. Torres-Rosario no longer controls given its more recent decision in United States v. Levasseur, and sent the case back to the district court for a proper historical analysis under Bruen.
Key points
- What changed: The First Circuit ruled the district court wrongly relied on Torres-Rosario and must now apply the Bruen historical-tradition test to Marshall's case.
- Standing limits: The court allowed Marshall's challenge to the denial of his firearm purchase to proceed, but found he lacked standing to challenge criminal prosecution for possession itself.
- DOJ restoration process: The district court must also weigh the DOJ's new § 925(c) relief process, under which the Attorney General had granted relief to 22 people as of February 2026.
- Nothing decided yet: Chief Judge David Barron's panel did not strike down § 922(g)(1) or restore Marshall's gun rights — it only reopened the question.
- Regional reach: The ruling applies within the First Circuit, covering Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Puerto Rico.
Quick take
This is a procedural win, not a final one. Marshall still has to convince the district court that his old, nonviolent DUI convictions don't fit the nation's historical tradition of disarmament. But for gun owners carrying decades-old convictions, the case signals that pre-Bruen precedents are losing their grip, and that argument now gets a real hearing.
Read the full story: ammoland.com