Sixth Circuit Upholds Federal Gun Ban Tied to Mental Health Rulings
The Sixth Circuit has upheld the federal law barring gun possession by people adjudicated as "mentally defective," ruling that history provides enough of a match to survive a Second Amendment challenge under Bruen.
Snapshot
A Sixth Circuit panel rejected a facial challenge to 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4) on October 29, 2026, affirming a Kentucky conviction tied to a prior Missouri mental-health detention. Judge Eric Murphy wrote the opinion, finding that historical laws confining dangerous mentally ill people serve as a valid analogue to today's firearm ban, as reported by Bearing Arms.
Key points
- The case: Alexander Laykovich was detained under a Missouri court order in January 2023 after being found a danger to himself or others, then barred from possessing guns.
- The arrest: In January 2024, he was stopped near Fort Knox, Kentucky, wearing body armor with eight firearms, ammunition, and fentanyl in his vehicle, leading to charges under § 922(g)(4).
- The ruling: The court found Laykovich still counts among "the people" under the Second Amendment's plain text, but said historical confinement laws for dangerous mentally ill individuals justify the modern ban.
- The gap: The panel noted the statute doesn't define what qualifies as a disqualifying mental illness, but said Laykovich's facial challenge failed regardless since he couldn't show the law is unconstitutional in all applications.
Quick take
Bearing Arms' Tom Knighton says he's torn: the Second Amendment protects "the people" broadly, yet society has long restricted the liberty of those judged dangerous to themselves or others. He argues this case is a weak vehicle for further review, but warns that if it reaches the Supreme Court, the outcome could ripple into red flag law disputes either way.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com