Supreme Court Passes on Maryland Gun-Free Zone Case Despite Thomas's Own Doubts
The Supreme Court has declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, leaving Maryland's broad gun-free-zone restrictions in place, even as Justice Clarence Thomas warned that states are stretching the "sensitive places" doctrine well past its historical limits.
Snapshot
Bearing Arms reports that the Court's refusal to take up Novotny v. Moore keeps Maryland's expansive carry restrictions intact. Justice Thomas agreed with denying review but flagged concerns about states redefining "sensitive places" too broadly. The author argues this leaves a contradiction unresolved at the Court's highest level.
Key points
- Petition denied: The Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore, meaning Maryland's current gun-free-zone framework stands without further review.
- Thomas's warning: Justice Clarence Thomas criticized states for stretching "sensitive places" designations beyond what history and tradition support.
- Vote versus words: Thomas agreed with the denial of review despite his stated concerns, a tension the author says undercuts the force of his warning.
- Patchwork persists: Bearing Arms notes that without Supreme Court intervention, states can continue expanding restricted-carry zones unevenly across the country.
Quick take
The author's core argument is that Thomas's criticism of sprawling sensitive-places laws means little if he's unwilling to vote for review when a case squarely presents the issue. For gun owners watching the post-Bruen landscape, this denial is a reminder that favorable language from individual justices doesn't translate into binding precedent. Until the Court actually takes a sensitive-places case and rules on the merits, states remain free to test how far they can push "gun-free zone" definitions, and carry rights will keep varying sharply depending on where you live.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com