Summit, N.J. Weighs Total Gun-Shop Ban, Inviting Legal Fight
The Common Council in Summit, New Jersey, voted 5-1 this week to advance an ordinance that would ban firearms retailers from every zoning district in the town, a step beyond the location restrictions other cities have used and one that could set up a direct Second Amendment court fight.
Snapshot
Summit currently has no gun shops, and most of the council wants it to stay that way. Councilman Dan Crisafulli, who backs the measure, says it would close ambiguity in the town's development code and cites concerns about neighborhood character, public safety, security and theft. The lone dissenting vote, Councilman Andrew Smith, warns the ban invites costly litigation.
Key points
- Scope: The ordinance would bar businesses that sell, rent, deal in or transfer firearms in all zoning districts, while exempting stores that sell only accessories like scopes, lights and mounts.
- Council vote: Advanced 5-1, with Crisafulli arguing the rule doesn't touch residents' right to "bear arms or own arms."
- Dissent: Councilman Smith, an attorney, says a total ban "could be construed by the current Supreme Court" as an unconstitutional restriction on arms, risking city money and resources.
- Legal backdrop: Bearing Arms notes Third Circuit precedent treating a flat prohibition on gun-store sales as inconsistent with Heller, and under Bruen, Summit would need to show historical grounding for such a categorical ban.
- Next step: Public comment is set for the Common Council's December 1 meeting before any final adoption.
Quick take
This is a tougher legal target than typical siting rules that merely push gun shops to industrial areas. A town-wide ban on the business of selling firearms looks more like a direct restriction on acquiring arms, the kind of policy Bruen's history-and-tradition test was built to scrutinize. If Summit adopts it, expect a challenge testing exactly how far "zoning" can be stretched to limit a constitutional right.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com