Guns

Fifth Circuit Says Second Amendment Covers Firearm Sales, Not Final Word

November 20, 2026

The Fifth Circuit ruled on November 19 that the Second Amendment's text covers firearm sales, rejecting the idea that dealer-licensing laws escape constitutional review simply because they regulate commerce rather than possession.

Snapshot

In United States v. Deare, a three-judge panel vacated a lower court's denial of a constitutional challenge brought by Jeremiah Micah Deare, who was convicted of conspiracy to deal firearms without a federal license. The case now returns to the Western District of Louisiana, where the court must decide whether the licensing and record-keeping requirements survive historical scrutiny under Bruen.

Key points

  • Core holding: The court stated plainly that "the plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms," rejecting a blanket carve-out for commercial regulation.
  • Government concession: Federal attorneys acknowledged at oral argument that the Second Amendment applies to commercial firearm sales, undercutting their own case.
  • Concurring judges: Judge James Ho compared firearm sellers to booksellers under the First Amendment, while Judge Andrew Oldham argued that restrictions on sales burden both buyers and sellers, and urged overturning the circuit's earlier Peterson decision.
  • Dissent: Judge Catharina Haynes argued sellers aren't named in the amendment's text and would have upheld the licensing requirement outright.
  • What's unresolved: The ruling doesn't strike down the federal dealer-licensing law or record-keeping rules; it sends the historical-tradition question back to the district court.

Quick take

This is a precedent-setting coverage ruling, not a final win. By making clear that firearm commerce falls inside the Second Amendment, the Fifth Circuit forces the government to defend dealer-licensing rules under Bruen's historical test rather than dismissing challenges outright. For FFLs and prospective dealers in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi, the practical outcome still depends on what the district court decides next.

Read the full story: ammoland.com